Wimsatt and Beardsley on the Intentional Fallacy

The intentional and affective fallacies

In The Verbal Icon (1954), William Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley describe two other fallacies which are encountered in the study of literature.

The "Intentional Fallacy" is the mistake of attempting to understand the author's intentions when interpreting a literary work. Such an approach is fallacious because the meaning of a work should be contained solely within the work itself, and attempts to understand the author's intention violate the autonomy of the work.

The "Affective Fallacy" is the mistake of equating a work with its emotional effects upon an audience. The new critics believed that a text should not have to be understood relative to the responses of its readers; its merit (and meaning) must be inherent.

Terms for the critical methods they opposed in this essay are romantic criticism, biographical criticism, and genetic criticism (AKA "source-hunting"). They allege that these methods begin "by trying to derive the standard of criticism from the psychological causes of the poem and in biography and relativism" (from the introduction to "The Affective Fallacy").

Judging a poem is like judging a pudding or a machine. One demands that it work. Poetry is a feat of style by which a complex of meaning is handled all at once. Poetry succeeds because all or most of what is said or implied is relevant; what is irrelevant has been excluded, like lumps from pudding and 'bugs' from machinery. In this respect poetry differs from practical messages, which are successful if and only if we correctly infer the intention. They are more abstract than poetry.

The poem is not the critic's own and not the author's (it is detached from the author at birth and goes about the world beyond his power to intend about it or control it). The poem belongs to the public. It is embodied in language [and] is an object of public knowledge.

. . . the way of objective criticism of works of art . . . enables us to distinguish between a skilful murder and a skilful poem. A skilful murder is an example which Coomaraswamy uses, and in his system the difference between murder and the poem is simply a 'moral' one, not an 'artistic' one, since each if carried out according to plan is 'artistically successful. We maintain that [asking "whether the work of art' ought ever to have been undertaken at all and so whether it is worth preserving'"] is an inquiry of more worth than [asking "whether the artist achieved his intentions"], and since [the former] and not [the latter] is capable of distinguishing poetry from murder, the name 'artistic criticism' is properly given to [the former].

Criticism is "the public art of evaluating poems" and requires "terms of objectification"--"The evaluation of the work remains public; the work is measured against something outside the author."

. . . author psychology can be historical too, and then we have literary biography, a legitimate and attractive study in itself . . . Yet there is danger of confusing personal and poetic studies; and there is the fault of writing the personal as if it were the poetic.

There is a difference between internal and external evidence for the meaning of a poem. [Public internal evidence of the meaning of the poem] is discovered through the semantics and syntax of a poem, through our habitual knowledge of the language, through grammars, dictionaries, and all the literature which is the source of dictionaries, in general, through all that makes a language and culture; while what is . . . external is private or idiosyncratic; not a part of the work as a linguistic fact: it consists of revelations (in journals, for example, or letters or reported conversations) about how or why the poet wrote the poem.


Comments

Anonymous said…
Hi people
I do not know what to give for Christmas of the to friends, advise something ....
Anonymous said…
Hello. Good day
Who listens to what music?
I Love songs Justin Timberlake and Paris Hilton
Anonymous said…
Thanks for the info, very much appreciated. Its a little to digest but will keep reading.
- www.blogger.com g
samsung ringtone
motorola ringtone
sony ericsson ringtone
nokia ringtone
Nidhi Bajaj said…
Thanks a lot for the information on WImsatt's essay. I have an exam to give.
Anonymous said…
Online Poker bonus no deposit - no deposit bonuses Good luck on the table :) free poker money Regards and sorry if spam for you.Play real money if you hungry , same cookie there - $150 bez depozytu za darmo graj i wygrywaj albo przegrywaj.
poker portal free poker money
pedro velasquez said…
Affective fallacy is a term from literary bet basketball criticism used to refer to the supposed error of judging or evaluating a text on the basis of its emotional effects on a reader. The term was coined by W.K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley as a principle of New Criticism. The New Criticism represented a new, largely academic, sportsbook approach to literary studies that focused on the literary text itself as the object of study and not as a social artefact that expressed the inner life of the artist or the society in which it was written. The New Critics attempted to make literary criticism into a more rigorous field, march madness modeled on the dominant paradigm of knowledge in modern society–science. In the process they forced critics to address the work of art itself and examine the nature of human creativity and artistic creation.
http://www.enterbet.com
istanbul said…
TTG Travel Agency is a leading travel agency and tour operator in istanbul Turkey with more than seven years of professional travel service. Because of our dedication and commitment to your needs istanbul travel we are able to offer you better quality of service at lower prices than other operators. http://www.istanbulhotels.com We provide hundreds of elaborately pre-designed Turkey tour packages, Turkey tours discounted, Guided turkey hotels and Turkey Tours, and we also provide customized travel service that is organized according to your specific needs and requirements http://www.istanbulhotels.com Our tours are professionally guided, intimate, and safe.

Popular posts from this blog

A Summary of Rolland Barthes' "From Work to Text"

I.A.Richards' Two Uses of Language

Analysis: The Fifth Stanza of William Blake's "The Tiger"